Gravitas Spark CrowdFunding

Tag: Microsoft

  • Short Prompts, Longer Impacts….

    Short Prompts, Longer Impacts….

    That was exhausting. And it was only a short week. Iranian civilization and the White House insider trading desk were given a bit more time to exist under autocratic regimes while Schrödinger’s ceasefire broke out everywhere but in the Strait of Hormuz and Lebanon. This paradox seemed to inspire Melania Trump who went to the Presidential podium to assure the world’s press that Epstein criminality was not a hoax, but at the same time that she “never had a relationship” with dear Jeffrey.  I’m thinking that’s a “relations” denial but that’s the Clinton nostalgia in me. Anyway, this very strange First Lady intervention has prompted some very short-term thinking about what exact Epstein bombshell is about to drop. The longer term implications might take a bit longer to decipher but, at the bare minimum, Melania appears to be keeping an eye on the catastrophic GOP polling for the mid-term elections this November. In fact, there were a few other developments this week which prompted relatively light commentary levels but could have far weightier longer term impact. Let’s start with a prompt, but one of the AI variety…

    Anthropic is the parent of the chat bot Claude which recently fell out with the Pentagon. Well, it looks like Anthropic might have prompted one of their LLM chat bots (large language models) rather too well. The latest reports suggest a cousin of Claude (certainly not Greg), Mythos, could be a bigger threat to the planet than Agent Orange in the Oval Office. Yeah, seriously. Apparently, and this is the really simple language version….Mythos was tasked/prompted to find vulnerabilities in software and systems deployed by the world’s biggest institutions, banks, utilities and blue chip companies. Mythos didn’t come back with one or two “exploits” or ways to hack software, it came back with hundreds even thousands of ways to hack into software systems. Mythos was SO good, Anthropic has taken the immediate decision not to release the model to the public. That’s not all. Some very senior people have been spooked by Mythos. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell called the CEOs of America’s biggest and most important banks into a closed-door meeting this week at the Treasury building in Washington, D.C. Expect to hear a lot more about Mythos and wonder how long before Polymarket or Kalshi start running betting books on the probability of world destruction being at the hands of digital weapons rather than nuclear weapons. But if we stick with the nuclear threat…..

    Earlier in the week, CNBC’s Trump-cheering anchor, Joe Kernen, was destroyed by former Transport Secretary, Pete Buttigieg in a toe-curling TV clip which has gone viral. Kernen tried desperately to amplify Tehran’s imminent nuclear capabilities but struggled to deflect from the strategically disastrous consequences of the Iran war including the shutting down of the Strait of Hormuz. “Whataboutism” is about to hit peak volume in MAGA land to drown out the inevitable rise in prices, inflation and voter discontent in the “golden age” of the USA. Peace talks begin at the weekend in Islamabad but the longer term consequences of world fuel supplies being cut by 10-20% will be felt for months to come. As each day passes, the global economy will pay the price of minimal shipping traffic passing the Strait of Hormuz. Before the war, daily shipping traffic averaged 130 vessels. Currently, Schrödinger’s ceasefire is delivering a daily traffic total of…… 6-7 vessels. Not 67, six…or seven. No wonder Trump is panicking, and that’s before he even checks the latest polls and actual votes.

    Amid all the ceasefire headlines, US voters are beginning to shift sharply. In Georgia, former Trump lovey, Marjorie Taylor Green’s seat witnessed a 25 point voter move towards the Democrats. In another swing state, Wisconsin, politicised Supreme Court elections saw a 20 point shift to the Democrats. According to the election analysis publication, the Downballot, Democrats have improved upon their 2024 presidential election margins by an average of 11% in special elections so far in 2026 and roughly 13% since the start of 2025. Prediction markets, Kalshi and Polymarket, are giving Democrats 88% odds of House control and 53% for the Senate in November 2026. Meanwhile, closer to home, Hungary goes to the polls this weekend with the real possibility of Trump and Putin fanboy, Viktor Orban, being ousted from power. A particularly eye-rolling moment during the last week of the campaign was the the arrival of US Vice-President JD Vance to complain about EU interference in the election……while on a trip to Hungary to interfere in their election. The EU-US relationship has never looked so broken, and will take years to repair. Indeed, it’s increasingly clear from a European perspective that no senior US leader gets a pass for staying quiet during this insanity. It’s not the only upside-down shift in the world we used to know…

    The downturn in the performance of software stocks like SAP, Salesforce and Microsoft has been a feature of financial market commentary in recent months, spawning multiple SaaSpocalypse headlines. I’m not convinced the valuation meltdown of software under the threat of AI is fully merited. Current valuation multiples, price/earnings below 20x, are back at pre-Covid levels and below those of lower growth consumer staples stocks like Walmart. In fact, Walmart is currently trading at higher valuation multiples than Amazon. Clearly, longer-term prospects for software have currently shifted in investors’ minds but perhaps the bigger story is in hardware. The semiconductor sector (ETF $SOXX) has risen by 108% over the past year while the software sector (ETF $IGV) has declined by 14% over the same period. This scale of market performance divergence is unprecedented and is a reminder (if the Strait of Hormuz isn’t already) that the securing of the supply of physical assets (atoms, molecules) is becoming THE strategic business edge in the global tech race, and not digital code (bits).

    A final thought on performance, as Ireland’s government considers new tax frameworks and savings products to encourage households and businesses to take risk with circa €340 billion sitting in bank deposits. Of course, Spark (and our 60-strong stable of companies we have funded) have skin in this game so one hopes the government is mindful of the benefits of diversification across the entire investing spectrum. A narrow solution steering monies into already publicly listed (and funded) companies would be a missed opportunity to drive investment into our capital starved start-up and SME sectors. Oh, and the investment returns in private assets are certainly worth investigation. Our own EIIS Private Portfolio service launched just over two years ago has funded 24 companies to date. Current valuations and funding milestones/marks indicate an estimated (average) performance by the entire portfolio of somewhere near 25%. Steady stuff, and early yet as these companies are just 2 years into their scaling up journey. However, there is one other BIG factor to consider. The EIIS tax rebate scheme does work, and all Spark investors have been receiving their tax rebates. Now, here’s the interesting twist. That return of cash completely changes the returns profile of the portfolio above. The average return  to investors (if you had invested in all 24 companies) is actually over 100%. In just 2 years, and that’s mostly cash, not just paper. Expect us to write lots more on this very soon.

    Let’s call that a little prompt, with a very big long-term impact.

  • The War Of Unintended Consequences…

    The War Of Unintended Consequences…

    I know. The headline should read “LAW” but where’s the law these days? Certainly, it’s nowhere near Washington as the new Trump fund raising “squeeze” is an emailed request for cash donations in exchange for “private national security briefings” straight from the desk of The Don himself. I kid you not. Anyway, let’s get back to the war, or ‘excursion’ per the Orwellian Oval Office. Clearly, things on the Iran war front are not going to plan. My particular favourite summary of the moment is a delicious one from The Economist: “Although Donald Trump claims to have destroyed 100% of Iran’s military capabilities, the remaining 0% is wreaking havoc on the global economy.” Now, the purpose of this article is not to re-hash all the negative first-order global impacts of the war ranging from higher fuel prices, to supply chain disruption, to inflation, to reduced growth….to interest rate hikes. Yuk! None of this helps financial markets or business in the near term but I’m intrigued by some of the second-order possibilities which could emerge from an extended period of uncertainty. I’m thinking of three areas in particular:

    AI Infrastructure: The simple math of a shock to the global economy is that financial flows dramatically shift. Quickly. Extra money will be needed to meet higher energy bills, economic stress etc. That money must come from somewhere else in the system. So, one thing to consider is that the hundreds of billions Saudi Arabia , UAE, and Qatar committed to the funding of AI infrastructure projects might just be needed to rebuild energy infrastructure closer to home. Current estimates of the cost of the attack on Qatar’s Ras Laffan LNG hub is up to $20 billion per annum . And the worst bit, the rebuild could take 5 years – so let’s call that $100 billion. There is a teeny weeny bit of irony here given the US tech broligarchs’ man in the big house (and ballroom) has screwed up royally. Current estimates suggest $4 trillion is needed to build data centres, processing chips, training models, memory chips and storage by 2030. A squeeze on access to that investment capital will favour the biggest balance sheets and cash flows like Google, Microsoft and Amazon. Not for the first time, I worry about OpenAI’s positioning in the middle of all this AI excitement (remember the famous FT graphic) and being attached to more than $1 trillion of AI projects. So might its bankers worry, watching its tiny balance sheet.

    Electric Revolution: There was a theory for years that Saudi Arabia was deliberately keeping the oil price lower in order to delay the electric/renewable revolution. Their thinking apparently was that if energy was cheap it would remove the urgency to seek alternatives to fossil fuels. So, with Asian buyers already paying over $170 per barrel of oil we are beginning to see some interesting developments. In a little more than 2 weeks, Chinese EV player, BYD Co, is seeing its showrooms packed with customers wanting to switch to EV models. From Bloomberg….”At a BYD Co car dealership in Manila’s financial district, demand for the Chinese company’s electric vehicles is so high that Matthew Dominique Poh said he’s seen a month’s worth of orders in just the past two weeks.”  This feels similar to the Covid-19 acceleration of remote working. Also, spare a thought for US auto manufacturers who have scaled back their EV ambitions to keep the Dearest Leader happy and have written off $55 billion of EV projects. Timing is everything they say…..Get ready for some pretty interesting EV headlines in the coming months.

    Defence: Ukraine was the wake-up call when the world’s second most powerful military power turned the Kremlin’s “3 day operation” into a battlefield quagmire which has decimated its stores of equipment and weaponry, incurred more than 1 million of its own military casualties and incredibly has now lasted longer than the Soviet Union’s WW2 conflict with Nazi Germany. Fast forward to today and we are witnessing the world’s most powerful military gain almost total superiority over Iran but now staring down the barrel (!) of a strategic disaster that “nobody ever expected” per the stable genius hurling ketchup against the walls of Mar-a-Lago. The trapping of 20% of the world’s fuel supplies in the Strait of Hormuz and the destruction of critical energy infrastructure in UAE, Saudi Arabia and Qatar has been achieved with drones which cost as little as $20,000 but require the US to quickly run through their stores of $2m missile air defence weapons. Astonishingly, the Pentagon is looking for an additional $200 billion of budget to fund this “excursion”. However, the bigger picture is that military strategy and economics have utterly changed. Drone warfare developed on the battlefields of Ukraine is the scary future. For some it will be opportunity. Check out the IPO this week of the Ukrainian drone software company, Swarmer, on the Nasdaq. The IPO price was $5 per share but by the close of its first day of trading the share price was $55. Just the 950% gain in one day of trading. Oh, and last year Swarmer had generated just $300,000 of revenues. The US military-industrial complex is having its “ChatGPT” moment and will soon embark on a massive drone warfare investment programme.

    Clearly, not all of the above is cheery stuff but it does feel like some ‘leaders’ in business, technology and investment are now facing very different prospects than they planned for just a few short weeks ago. And, there doesn’t seem to be a “TACO” option this time.

  • Software Is Eating Your Pension….

    Software Is Eating Your Pension….

    Is it time to rip up our favoured playbooks? No, I’m not trying to steer Andy Farrell after that first half ‘traffic cone’ tackling effort in Paris. Nor will I hold out any hope of Britain’s Labour Party saving its government from the existential fallout of ignoring its own “Prince of Darkness” links to Epstein. Sir Keir Starmer’s premiership is already “dead in the water” but I will stick with the trading theme. Long-time political commentators are rightly appalled that Peter Mandelson tipped off Jeffrey Epstein and his elite rolodex/assets about a €500 billion bailout of the euro currency during the Greek debt crisis. The €500 billion number is huge in its own right but the derivative opportunities in banking debt, currencies, bond markets etc at the time were in the trillions and available for exploitation by Epstein & Co without any obvious trace. So, following on from last week’s article, we promised to dig deeper into the huge AI numbers hitting our screens. Actually, we won’t. Instead, we will focus on a related huge number with potentially massive knock-on/derivative investment implications.

    For me, the big number this week is the $1 trillion of value wiped from software stocks (and their SaaS subscription/business models) in just 6 days of trading. Of course, this is directly connected to the threat of AI and some developments, in particular, from the Anthropic/Claude suite of products which are making massive strides in assisting coders and companies to develop/manage their own work processes. Software, of course, is the incumbent go-to solution for companies seeking to optimise work processes and engagement with their customers. Indeed, the venture capital guru, Marc Andreessen, in 2011 was moved to say  “software is eating the world”. From Netflix to Uber to Amazon, digital subscriptions gave companies and consumers access to technology-optimised services. As AI invades the digital opportunity, software is possibly no longer the ‘always’ solution on the Boardroom table. In fact, software could be on the displacement menu itself. The twin threats of AI are summarised well by Business Insider:

     

    “First, if employees get more efficient using AI tools, companies may not need to buy as many business software subscriptions. That would dent the growth of “seats” or how many subscriptions software companies sell. Each employee has a seat, so if there’s no new hiring, growth stalls.

     The second threat is more existential. If AI tools and AI agents get good enough, companies could replace the software they use entirely and instead rely on new AI-powered workflows. And with AI coding tools showing big improvements lately, companies could even develop their own software, without needing to buy it from established vendors.”

     

    There are plenty of analysts and observers who disagree with the gloomy interpretation of AI’s eventual impact on software companies like SAP, Salesforce, Adobe, Figma and HubSpot. However, these company share prices falling by 30-40% in just one month, is telling us the ‘fear’ is real. The $1 trillion of value evaporation in less than a week is not an earth-shattering number given some individual companies are valued in the trillions alone. But… perhaps looking at the software value obliteration in isolation is misguided. The commentariat might think software fears are ‘overdone’ but, if you have a pension, this might be the less scary of TWO outcomes. The first is that software stocks growth and valuations are hit severely by AI replacement. However, there’s a second set of updated numbers/data to take a look at. While the software sector was being hammered, the AI/Cloud giants were announcing quarterly results. Interestingly, their earnings and sales growth numbers were pretty much ignored as the market focused on just one number; capital expenditure spend on AI infrastructure and development. Last week Facebook promised $135 billion of INVESTMENT in 2026 which equates to their total sales in 2023. Microsoft told us their number was circa $105 billion. This week it was Google and Amazon’s respective turns to talk the AI ‘space race’…

    Google, perceived as the AI leader these days, told the market it would spend a cool $185 billion. That equates to its total revenues in 2020(!). Meanwhile, Jeff Bezos seems happy to test out the theory that “Democracy Dies in Darkness” at the investment-starved Washington Post, as his primary wealth creation vehicle, Amazon, announces a planned $200 billion capex spend for 2026. So, the Big 4 are up for a $625 billion investment splurge this year and probably every year for the foreseeable future. That looks like a bet of $3 trillion to $5 trillion on AI, and I’m just wondering what the ‘risk’ calculations could be? I chose the ‘space race’ phrasing earlier deliberately. It feels like the prospect of AI failure for these companies is existential in terms of economic power and analogous to the geopolitical calculations at the height of the Cold War in the 1960s. Well, the historians would probably agree that Reagan’s “Star Wars”  broke the Soviet empire. It’s too early to tell who will ‘break’ in the AI race but software is in the crosshairs right now. However, the sense that big tech including software is ‘going for broke’ introduces a very new risk for financial markets.

    The beauty of software and SaaS business models is recurring revenues, huge scalability at minimal incremental cost, 80-90% margins and enormous cash flow generation. The end result can be seen in the massive spending plans of Big Tech; these companies’ balance sheets were sitting on enormous cash piles (or equivalent liquidity). Simply put, these were the most robust (credit risk) companies on the planet. Pension funds, family offices, sovereign wealth funds and Swiss bank accounts loved the security/risk safety attached to loans and bonds issued by tech/software companies. These instruments were considered “defensive”. Now, not so much.

    Stock/equities markets (as my former boss Terry Smith used to point out to me) occupy 28 of the 30 pages of the Financial Times. But, the last two pages covering debt, currencies, commodities etc are much more significant for financial markets. Now the bonds and loans associated with big technology companies are receiving intense scrutiny (and investor selling) as they each seek to out-spend their cash and balance sheet credibility. This has incredibly important implications for your pension. The credibility of the United States and global technology stocks are being reviewed for their ‘risk safety’. Some serious investment institutions are already acting and re-positioning. This doesn’t mean just selling. What investors are buying at the moment is telling too. Here’s a few data snippets to alert you to what is happening right now….

     

    *Software sector selling activity is the worst since 2008

    *Software valuations – forward price/earnings multiples of 20x – are now at levels (low) not seen since 2014.  

    *Now the buying: defensive consumer staples companies (Nestle, Mondelez, Heinz etc) have been up 1% on consecutive days while technology sector companies fell 1% on the same days. That divergence of performance has not happened since ….2000.

    *The same consumer staples stocks are experiencing buying intensity (“RSI” for the technicians) not seen since 1995. Other indicators (DMA 200 day) are 4.2 standard deviations above average.

     

    It looks like people are buying ordinary stuff; petfood, protein, household goods, chocolate….. really boring but real. We have written before that investors are flocking to atoms (real) and hedging/selling their risk with bits(digital code). One suspects the meltdown in crypto land (Bitcoin at $65,000, down over 50% from its highs) is also partly driven by digital ‘fear’. So, for those keeping an eye on the headlines and their pensions, you might want to check with your advisors on three areas:

     

    1. Pension exposure to technology (software or AI spend). It could be as high as 30% of your portfolio.
    2. Pension exposure to defensive real stuff. It could be as low as 5% of your portfolio.
    3. Pension exposure to the USA. It could be as high as 70% but there is currently a lawless armed militia running around the country, a Supreme Court in dereliction of its duty, international grift on an epic scale and the real threat of mid-term election suspension.

     

    The advisors won’t have all the answers but it should be on ALL pension radars. This period of history offers mind-boggling opportunity but we must be also aware that there is an unusual confluence of technology ambition/confidence and global political leadership operating in an environment where traditional values and rules are being disregarded. Hopefully, rules-based leadership will return soon but here’s a warning from Andrew Ross Sorkin’s book, 1929:

     

    “It’s a haunting elegy for a fractured era, a timeless reminder that progress is fragile, choices have repercussions, and the flaws embedded in the human condition are ours to confront”

     

    Might be time to make better choices and confront those flaws (including White House ape videos)….

  • Back To School For A Monster Theme…

    Back To School For A Monster Theme…

    I’m running out of expletives. It’s a sort of “FOMO” thing which rules out obsessing on Labour’s implosion or the Epstein “hoax” which mysteriously keeps removing only British citizens from high profile roles. No, the headlines driving my heightened state of anxiety are derived from a familiar theme. However, it’s a theme which is now hitting warp speed. We have previously written that the best pulse-take of the monster AI trend was tracking the “picks and shovels” of AI/cloud infrastructure rather than the “gems” of digital intelligent progression. Well, this week is turning into a “biggie” for the AI infrastructure theme. I’d highlight three key developments and a few other snippets. So, here goes….

    The creation of start-up billion dollar ‘unicorns’ has hardly any scarcity value these days. Maybe, we should think in trillions. Step forward almost 50-years old Oracle. Who knew Larry Ellison’s database software business would rack up a trillion dollar enterprise value at the beginning of this week? Probably nobody. Even the Wall Street analysts paid to follow every line of the Oracle business and financial model were truly shocked by the big reveal in Oracle’s quarterly update. In fact, earnings results were slightly shy of expectations. But, the share price proceeded to rocket 40%. Why? The future contract work backlog in its cloud(AI) infrastructure business grew 359% to $455 billion. I mentioned “warp speed” earlier so here’s what caught the eye. Oracle’s cloud revenues from Amazon, Google and Microsoft grew by 1,500% but the entire division this year is annualising revenues of circa $10 billion. That number will be $144 billion by 2030. Welcome to trickle-down AI economics. Oracle was barely mentioned in AI giddiness a year ago, now its owner is the richest man in the world. Oracle is not the only AI ‘unknown’ making waves.

    Anyone heard of Nebius? No, me neither until this week but I do remember its former Russian search/e-commerce platform, Yandex. Anyway, Russian sanctions forced a sale of the Russian assets leaving Nebius as an Amsterdam-listed company specializing in cloud computing (GPU) infrastructure. This week Microsoft signed an agreement worth up to $19.4 billion for Nebius in exchange for 5 years’ access to its GPU datacentre infrastructure in Vineland, New Jersey. Nebius’ market value before that news was less than $15 billion. Not surprisingly, the share price has roared 50% higher and the company is now seeking to raise $3 billion in fresh funds to accelerate its growth plans. This was not the only Dutch tech/AI zinger story this week…..

    Eindhoven-based ASML is the world’s dominant player in critical lithography technology used in chip manufacturing equipment. A single machine can contain up to 100,000 parts and cost $300-400 million. Clearly, semiconductor chips and AI are thematically closely connected. But investing in an AI start-up caught ASML analysts on the hop. ASML has just invested $1.5 billion in French AI player, Mistral, for a circa 11% stake valuing Mistral at close to $14 billion. Remember, Mistral raised $385m in late 2023 with a $2 billion valuation and early investor support from BNP Paribas, AndreessenHorowitz, Lightspeed Ventures and telecoms entrepreneur, Xavier Niel. Less than 2 years later, the Mistral valuation is racing towards a 7-8x return for those early investors. Apart from being an example of multi-layer AI investment activity, the deal is being hailed as a boost to Europe’s AI and semiconductor chip sovereignty.  And maybe I’m not the only one feeling a bit FOMO….

    It seems Ireland’s Taoiseach, Micheál Martin, has been thinking ‘sovereign’ too and looking at France’s early initiatives in funding AI startups. The Business Post has reported that Martin has sought the help of Eir owner, Xavier Neil (see above), in establishing an AI/tech incubator modelled on his highly successful Station F start-up campus. There might be good reason why Ireland needs to increase the pace of its AI and start-up readiness. I thought the next few little snippets should be focusing minds in Government buildings and elsewhere:

     

    Private investing: The UK debt market is worrying many, but on a more positive note it was interesting to see Hargreaves Lansdowne and Schroders join forces to offer UK retail investors the opportunity to add private assets to their pension pots. Note to Irish government – start-ups need investor incentives first, then campuses.

     

    Consumer behaviour: Wildfire Systems’ 2025 Consumer Shopping Trends Report shows 61% of consumers are now using generative AI tools like ChatGPT as a tool for deal-hunting.

     

    Company growth speeds: Stripe’s Indexing the AI Economy report shows AI companies reaching $1m annual recurring revenues (ARR) 4 months faster than even the fastest growing SaaS/software companies. And… AI companies reaching $5m revenues are reaching that milestone 3x faster.

     

    I feel my back-to-school mantra should read:    The future is private, AI and fast. Very fast.

     

     

  • The Euphoric Wisdom Of Crowds

    The Euphoric Wisdom Of Crowds

    I laughed a lot at a very sad funeral this week. Emotions, eh. I’m hopeful this weird juxta-positioning of emotions is a kind of human coping strategy, rather than a sociopathic tell. Then again, the mourning crowd laughed at the brilliant life narration too. Back at my desk, a flurry of headlines hitting the screen prompted a further emotional conflict. Surging extreme weather events globally, Europe battered by tariff tyranny, Gaza starved and Ukrainian cities terrorised by Russian bombardment are hardly sources of optimism for the progress of our species. And, yet……I’m picking up a very euphoric vibe from the financial markets. Strangely for this publication, I’m not that interested in retro-fitting the euphoria with some financial rationale along the lines of falling cost of money(rates), corporate earnings, tech innovation or economic cycles. The sheer phenomenon of financial euphoria is worth highlighting first. Then we can do some thinking, all of us.  Now for the euphoria…..

    The “wisdom of crowds” leans on the idea that large groups of people (markets) are collectively more likely to be correct than individual experts. What is particularly striking about current financial market behaviours is that there is a wide variety of “crowds” ignoring the gloom-filled headlines and seeing a better future out there. However, that optimism is not exactly a new phenomenon. Note that financial markets typically enjoy positive returns in seven out of every ten years. In other words, it pays off to be relatively optimistic. However, in this piece we are looking at something more, evidence of euphoric excess. Let’s try a few of these crowds for starters…..

     

    *The crypto crowd: Bitcoin is hitting record highs of $118,000 while the entire crypto ecosystem has now surpassed $4 trillion in value.

    *The IT crowd: If one uses pre-2018 sector classifications, then technology stocks’ weighting in the S&P 500 is above 45%. That’s way higher than the dotcom bubble of 2000.

    *The ‘Magnificent 7’ crowd: There’s now, not one, but two Big Tech companies with market values in excess of $4 trillion. For context (and wobbly comparison), the $8 trillion combination of Microsoft and Nvidia alone would rank 3rd globally as a single country GDP.  

    *The meme-stock crowd: In 2021 it was Gamestop and the Robinhood day-traders. Now, it’s Kohl,’s (retail) Krispy Kreme(donuts) OpenDoor (estate agent) and American Eagle with Sydney Sweeney dominating social media, chat rooms and…. Wall Street trading volumes.

    *The AI/Cloud crowd: Earlier in the year Microsoft CEO, Satya Nadella, in a Davos interview stated he “was good for $80 billion of investment in 2025” in AI/Cloud infrastructure. Scratch that. This week he said the number will be $120 billion. Google said $85 billion (up from $75 billion) as Big Tech companies look like they will do a giddy AI spend of close to $400 billion in 2025.

    *The M&A crowd: Research data from Pitchbook shows robust merger and acquisition (M&A) activity in Q2, marking the third consecutive quarter for deal value to hit about $1 trillion across roughly 12,000 transactions. It’s not just tech showing confidence. Railway giants Norfolk Southern and Union Pacific are doing an $85 billion merger to create the first transcontinental railway line in US history.

    *The retail crowd: Barclays research points to retail investors as the “primary driver” of the recent stock market rally. In the past month alone, retail investors poured $50 billion into US stocks and now account for up to 20% of daily trading volume on Wall Street. That’s double the levels seen before the pandemic.

    *The VC crowd: The challenged venture capital (VC) world has been looking for a genuine positive pulse-take via an IPO exit. As I write, Greylock Partners, Sequoia and Index Venture will be the VCs doing cartwheels tonight after the largest VC-backed tech IPO in years, Figma, tripled in value within hours of its NYSE debut to almost $50 billion. Or… will they be wondering how they got the selling (IPO) price so wrong?

    It is entirely possible many of the above trends are rooted in fundamental investment theses but suggestions of dangerous  “euphoria” can be found in aggregate valuations of US stocks. The average price/sales valuation multiple (per Bloomberg) for US stocks is a punchy 3.3x. Furthermore, Warren Buffett’s favoured sanity check of comparing the market value(cap) of all publicly traded US companies with total US GDP currently stands at 212%. As a risk guide, Warren is usually uneasy when that number is over 100%. My own two personal favourites in the euphoria beauty parade are more esoteric but tell their own stories.

    First, it is no secret Facebook/Meta and others in the AI “arms race” are desperately looking for AI talent. However, the numbers are starting to look bonkers. According to Wired magazine, at least one prospective employee was offered a 3-year billion dollar salary package to join Meta. Others were offered hundreds of millions (rumoured to be Mira Murati’s Thinking Machines Lab team) but here’s the best bit…. the prospective hires turned down the offers!! Now, here’s a few other proposals that were turned down as recently as November 2022.

    If that date sounds familiar, you might have been vowing to stay away from markets at the time as stocks hit bear market lows spooked by rising global interest rates. Online car retailer, Carvana, was “on sale” that day after its share price had collapsed by almost 99% from its highs the previous year. Nobody wanted to touch it. As of today, it’s up more than 10,000% since then. Fear and greed, emotions eh. Oh, and Meta’s share price on that day after a rough year for the Zuck was $88.91 per share. It’s up almost 800% since then but here’s the best bit….in barely one trading session after its excellent quarterly results this week, Meta’s share price jumped by about $88.91 per share. That number sound familiar?

    No more teasing. The key point is that confidence is surging in public markets. The quieter, less public private markets have struggled to generate similar headlines. Yes, there are pockets of excess. However, it would be foolish to ignore the ‘wisdom’ of the public market crowds. Ultimately, higher trading activity levels, record capex investment, big M&A deals and higher valuations will feed into private markets and smaller companies. Indeed, you might have to get used to the giddy headlines for a bit longer. Goldman Sachs have done a bit of historical analysis and concluded that spikes in speculative trading actually precede abnormally high returns on a one-year time horizon. Don’t stay too long at the beach….the YOLO crowd might be on to something.

     

                                      N.H.  RIP

     

     

  • AI…AI…AI…AI…I Just Don’t Know

    AI…AI…AI…AI…I Just Don’t Know

    I’m going to have to up my game. Not just tennis. As a frequenter of the occasional business discussion panel, this week threw up a very different type of panelist. The Dublin Tech Summit at the RDS hosted a panel discussion on AI which featured contributions from a meta-human avatar created by AI, named Anja. Quite unnerving in a way. If it had been a horse on the panel, I don’t think it would have unsettled me more. Mind you, the no-clothes Emperor Taco Trump guy can’t be far away from appointing a horse to the Senate soon. Anyway, I digress as humans do. Back to AI, and I was thinking it would be no harm to highlight a few significant AI datapoints and developments which have caught my eye in recent weeks. First, the data.

    The Stargate data centre project backed by OpenAI, Japan’s Softbank, Oracle and Nvidia and to be built in the UAE is estimated to eventually have the capacity to consume 5GW of power, For context, that’s the power consumption equivalent of the entire island of Ireland. And, Ireland would already be considered a global leader in terms of data centre capacity as a proportion of the total energy grid, about 21%. Clearly, AI and its critical data centre/cloud infrastructure is moving at pace to meet expected future AI usage demand. The pulse-take on AI investment pace has been chip-maker, Nvidia, who reported quarterly results this week. Revenues for Nvidia (despite Trump China tariffs/blocks) are still growing at almost 70% but this doesn’t quite capture the scale of growth. Two years ago, at the time of ChatGPT’s launch, quarterly revenues at Nvidia were $6 billion. Now, they are at $44 billion. Furthermore, Nvidia plans to invest $500 billion to build AI infrastructure in the US. Note, things have also moved on from  ChatGPT and other Gen AI tools (like Gemini and Claude) as the drivers of AI investment. The big move now is to “Agentic AI” or “AI Agency”.

    Agentic AI is not a pilot or learning model wanting users to test its knowledge. No, this is the real “doing” stuff which companies are now paying to integrate in their work flows. According to CB Insights research, enterprise AI and copilots will generate $13 billion of revenues by the end of 2025 across a variety of activities from sales to coding to customer service. That’s a growth rate of 155% year-on-year and a wake-up call for most companies; the reality is that their competitors are likely deploying AI to dramatically improve productivity and costs. One wouldn’t want to be in the spectator seats for too long and it’s not just a corporate caution. At a sovereign level, Dubai has offered all its citizens free access to the premium ChatGPT Plus service which normally costs $20 per month. The digital information race is truly ‘on’ but there’s also a hardware story emerging.

    OpenAI has just acquired  Jony Ive’s AI hardware start-up, Io Products. The former Apple key man, whose design credits include the iPhone and iPad, will now lead design at OpenAI as the company pushes deeper into hardware. The move highlights a trend of VC-backed companies buying one another amid a shifting tech landscape and a hunger for talent. However, it is worth noting that this is the largest private-to-private acquisition ever at $6.4 billion. Indeed, over 40% (7) of all-time $1B+ private-to-private acquisitions have happened in just the last year. OpenAI, Databricks, and Stripe have each spent over 15% of their total funding to date on acquisitions in the last 2 years. Don’t forget Anja too. Venture capital investment in humanoid robots are estimated to double this year to over $2 billion per CB Insights data. Then consider that there are 660 million people in Asia (average age 27) using digital companions. That disturbing little gem came from anthropologist, Dr Lollie Mancey, in a recent RTE interview and….. I just don’t know. I’m not alone.

    The fascinating story of Irish recycling software company, AMCS, and its $2 billion wealth creation story was told by its founder, Jimmy Martin, at the Renatus/Fitzgerald Power “Real Deal” SME conference in Goffs this week. When asked about AI, he wisely declined to predict the future but did make one very interesting and more definitive point. As a hugely successful observer of ‘margin’ in industry ecosystems, Martin was quick to identify the monopolistic power of the big 3 cloud infrastructure players, Microsoft, Amazon and Google. For me, the unanswered question of who will be the winner(s) will focus on the following :

     

    1. The manufacturers of the critical semiconductor chips
    2. The owners of data centre infrastructure
    3. The providers of energy/power capacity
    4. Sovereign/digital alignment (China, Europe or US).

     

    I really don’t know, particularly the geopolitical/sovereign and energy/power questions. However, I do think it interesting that in recent days companies exposed to the nuclear power industry have seen big share price moves. Not coincidentally, the US and a number of European countries have been embracing a nuclear industry revival at the same time. Plenty to ponder, not all of it comfortable. Isn’t that right, Anja?

  • Torn In The USA: A European View

    Torn In The USA: A European View

    I know, I know. Who wants views, just get this bloody vote over with. Well, we hope the bloody bit doesn’t come true but, if you want Hitler’s generals and your chief cheerleader is a just-revealed Putin (pay)pal, then you never know. Anyway, forget the politics. Let’s pause and reflect where the US economy is today, not where it will be in 11 days. Also, note that financial markets, for the first time in 2024, through emerging market equities and inflation-measuring instruments (bonds, gold) are beginning to think about a different USA to come. However, in this article I’d like to highlight ten things which the average European would envy about our US ally today.

     

    1. The US stock market now accounts for 50% of the global total, but is home to less than 5% of the world’s population.

     

    1. The IMF this week (Financial Times) has provided some explanation for this dominance by highlighting stagnant European productivity growth since 2005. In the same two decade period US productivity has rocketed by 40%.

     

    1. Technology you say. You’d be right. Just 5 US technology companies – Apple, Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Meta/Facebook – have a collective market value of $12.2 trillion which is more than the value of any other stock market in the world. Indeed, the new AI chip star, Nvidia, is worth more than the entire stock markets of five of the G7 countries.

     

    1. The old stuff is going well too. US domestic oil production hit 13.4 million barrels a day in August. That’s the highest production number for ANY country(even OPEC) in history. The US is a NET exporter of oil while Europe watches its eastern gas pipelines anxiously. But, you won’t hear that on Fox News. Drill baby, drill…just not the facts.

     

    1. Not surprisingly, US banks with the biggest corporate customers in the world are doing quite well. US banking giant, JP Morgan, has a market value of $540 billion which exceeds the combined value of Europe’s top 10 banks.

     

    1. Maybe Europe will disrupt US economic hegemony and bounce back with AI? Ehhhh…that’s not looking like a great bet right now. The sheer cost of talent and large-language-models (LLM) used to train and build AI applications are turning the AI race into Big Tech 2.0. Recent newsflow would suggest it’s only Microsoft/OpenAI, Amazon, Meta and Google who have the deep pockets to win the race. And, Asia will be watching anxiously too. The Asian dominance of hardware/semiconductor chip production is in “transition” as Taiwan’s TSMC just told the markets that the production yields in its new Arizona plant are 4% higher than in its home base Taiwan.

     

    1. Speaking of home bases…US home owners are sitting on $32 trillion of value attached to their home equity. That’s a quadrupling of property wealth from the $8 trillion low recorded as recently as 2012. How did that happen?

     

    1. Jobs, and lots of them. The US economy is at full employment, the highest seen in 100 years. Oh, and average hourly earnings are up 26% since 2020. In fact, US real (adjusted for inflation) wage growth is up 26% since 2000. More companies too…

     

    1. Back in 2015, 2.8 million new companies were formed in that year. The number in 2023 was 5.5 million. That’s a near doubling of start-up activity in less than 10 years. And…. money doesn’t just talk.

     

    1. Risk earns rewards. High risk venture capital (VC) is the oxygen of innovation and explains much of the US tech dominance. The US capital markets are the source of 50% of ALL venture capital funding globally. Asia is 40%. And Europe…… ahem…… 5%.

     

    That’s enough. But, I could mention military dominance too as Russia impales itself on imperial delusion in Ukraine and is now resorting to throwing North Korean troops into meat-grinder combat action on its own soil in Kursk. Of course, the US is not in a perfect place, leaving aside its toxic partisan politics. Its health and hate crises seem to be impossible to address by looking overseas for solutions or perspective. Indeed, the sheer presence of 350 million guns in the most prosperous land on the planet are a startling reflection of fear in the midst of so much opportunity. We can only watch over the next few days, as US citizens cast their votes. The list of ‘wins’ above looks like a fabulous starting point. The polls suggest voters are not so sure.

    As Europeans, we can attest to similar ‘win’ lists for Germany and the UK ten years ago. Not so today, and their voters painfully know they played their part in believing not-so-great-again political calculations in new energy and trade policies. Tick tock…..

     

     

  • Themes Checklist For The Beach

    Themes Checklist For The Beach

    The weather forecast isn’t great.  I’d usually suggest some couch thinking time but that phrasing has now become a politically-charged innuendo in the US which tops off possibly the most bizarre presidential campaign month ever. Don’t ask about couches or dolphins, or JD Vance. And, he thought having no children was the problem…..! Anyway, given the amount of delusion in the air, I’m going to suggest a beach plan. That might be the wrong plan, but thematically we might be on the right track in the world of finance. So, for those enjoying some time off, one can review and reflect on the following:

     

    Old economy: Our suggestion “Investors Need The Old Economy Too” in May started subtle, then went full hammer. This move hasn’t just been a tech shift from software to more traditional hardware manufacturing. Say hello to the ‘great rotation’. The old economy stocks roared in July. The top performing sectors in the US were industrials, financials, utilities, basic materials and real estate. As an illustration of the scale of rotation, note technology stocks actually had a negative month (-2%) while US regional banks and housebuilders rocketed 19% and 17% respectively.

     

    Smaller companies: We have written “Betting On Small Can Really Win” but boy oh boy did it rock in July. Smaller companies tracked by the Russell 2000 index whipped the performance of the large company S&P 500 by 10 percentage points. That’s the largest monthly divergence between size cohorts ever recorded in history.

     

    Climate and cleantech: Another theme close to our hearts. VC Breakthrough Energy Ventures backed by Bill Gates has just raised the largest climate fund of the year with a funding round of $839m. In Europe, the momentum is good too. Private equity deal values in European cleantech are now on track for their best year ever(Source: Pitchbook).

     

    Fintech: Stripe and Revolut valuations in recent private share sale activity have jumped by 40-50% and London remains a fintech investment hotbed. Latest British Business Bank data tells an interesting City story –  the UK fintech sector is attracting 11% of global VC investment (and 48% of all investment in Europe), a share only exceeded by the US.

     

    UK Comeback: In March we wrote “Time For A UK Recovery” and waited for credibility and competence to return to Westminster. The scorecard at the moment looks pretty good: UK equities are seeing the strongest inflows of foreign institutional investment for years (Source: BOA), and on the currency front, the GBP (formerly known as the “Great British Peso”) has been the strongest major currency performer in the year so far (Source: Bloomberg).

     

    Digital infrastructure: We wrote “Get Ready For The Cloud Wars” back in November and this has morphed into a global foot race to acquire, invest, service and build the infrastructure of our digital/AI future. From data centres to state-of-the-art chip manufacturing plants the investment giants are moving fast to get involved. While Microsoft opens a data centre every three days, it feels like the likes of Blackrock, Apollo and Blackstone are competing for digital infrastructure headlines every few days too. In fact, Blackstone estimate digital infrastructure spend by top tech companies will exceed $1 trillion over the next 5 years.

     

    Wall Street veterans would say  ‘the trend is your friend’. So, we aren’t giving up on any of these themes just yet. However, we will return to two critical risk factors for many of these themes in a later article. Geopolitical risk from Taiwan to Iran to US electoral chaos looks like it is escalating rather than fading. US politics can make for electric watching (with the shock too) but the just announced prisoner swap deal between Russia and the US was significant. The allied multinational effort by the Biden White House shows the value of joined up thinking and shared values but the planet faces other bigger challenges. Arguably, our highly charged politics needs to address the fundamental challenge of climate and electricity too. For another day, but the race to decarbonise and electrify the global economy is definitely not on track…..

     

  • A Few Pictures Of Promise

    A Few Pictures Of Promise

    So, despite all the scary headlines and genuine bad-actor or bad-bot risks, artificial intelligence (AI) now officially rules the financial world. Nvidia, the AI chip superstar, is now worth a staggering $3.327 trillion and has overtaken Apple and Microsoft as the most valuable company on the planet. Or to put it in simple futuristic terms, investors are expecting greater returns from this company over time than from any other company operating today. To quantify the sheer scale and speed of the change in expectation from investors, let me paint a slightly different picture. Just over 3 years ago in March 2021 the market value of Nvidia was just $330 billion. So, in just over 3 years financial markets have changed their view of Nvidia’s future by $3 trillion. Wowzers. Now, in the spirit of changing views, allow me to present a few more pictures which promise better things than current headlines might suggest.

    The perception and headlines written post the recent European elections would suggest Green/climate candidates suffered setbacks and populist near-term promises won the day. Indeed, closer to home, Green Party leader, Eamonn Ryan, has decided to step down. A rushed analysis might suggest voters have decided that climate crisis policies have stunted growth and opportunity. However, the following chart from the Financial Times using World Bank data suggests reducing carbon emissions can be achieved, or can be ‘decoupled’, while countries’ growth trajectories diverge in a positive way:

     

     

    Another area perceived to be struggling with our ambition to decarbonise the global economy is electricity. In our last article we certainly identified a significant need, and worrying potential shortage, for critical metals like copper to assist the electrification of economic activity. However, a more encouraging perspective might emerge from an unusual source. China gets bad press on coal, pollution and environmental damage but its electricity story is a global leader. The excellent writer, Noah Smith, has pointed out that China is miles ahead of every other country and could arguably be described as the world’s “first major electrostate”.  The next chart or picture doesn’t lie and is based on data from sustainability research group, RMI:

     

     

    Perhaps, China is a good example of how countries or regions can gain a laggard reputation but can then become a leader. For example, Europe’s productivity growth has lagged the US for almost 2 decades. Incredibly, the GDPs of the US and EU were roughly the same size back in 2008. Today, the US economy is 44% larger than that of the EU. The productivity story in this Financial Times graphic is pretty stark and uses LSE Group data:

     

     

     

    Clearly, the digital revolution has been a big factor in that productivity divergence. However, it’s more nuanced than just digital adoption. Bluntly, US capital backed its entrepreneurs and its flagship digital leader companies in a big way, and in frustrating contrast to a more risk-averse European business and investment culture. It’s not just a finance thing. The US became the coding and software capital of the world. Software developer talent was paid extremely well, were encouraged to create more products and became the rock stars of the US economy. So, would you be surprised to know that the US now employs fewer software developers than it did in 2018? This chart from ADP Research might surprise….

     

     

    Then I read an interesting piece from the excellent Angular Ventures VC newsletter this morning and started to think some more. The newsletter cited a recent post written by Chris Paik at Pace Capital which has raised eyebrows in the tech world. The title alone was provocative.. “ The End of Software”. He reckons AI and large-language-models (LLMs) are driving the cost of software downwards like content creation in the early 2000s. He concluded with the punchy view, “Majoring in computer science today will be like majoring in journalism in the late 90’s.” Ouch. Angular Ventures’ David Peterson can see some merit in Paik’s view on the direction of software travel and paints the picture succinctly:

     

    “It’s uncontroversial at this point to say that LLMs are surprisingly good at writing code. Is the code as elegant or performant as the code written by an experienced software developer? No. Could you ask an LLM to write a custom piece of enterprise-grade software? Also, no. But even today LLMs are good enough to empower non-technical people to write small snippets of code – tiny, trivial, seemingly insignificant lines – to solve problems which they previously thought impossible to solve by themselves. And that is more meaningful than it seems, because it has the potential to shift the clearing price of software itself.”

     

    My own thinking is still evolving but I do believe Europe and its productivity stagnation might now be an opportunity. That might seem a little bold but the AI talent race is looking good for Europe. In turn, innovative applications of AI in the European economy could close the software and productivity gap with the US. A recent report from VC Atomico on “The State of Tech” states that Europe has more AI talent than the US. Here’s the encouraging picture:

     

     

    Again, the headlines might suggest the US is leading in the AI race but the talent story will be a critical driver of future growth rates. So, lots to think about and, whether it’s electricity, carbon emissions, AI or productivity, readers should be keenly aware of the dangers of chasing rear-view mirror headlines. The data and charts can paint an opportunistic picture not seen by the headline writers. As a final thought, and an illustration of change, the Nvidia $3.3 trillion valuation mark prompted me to look at other historic charts and ‘beginnings’. So, here goes….. Nvidia’s current market value is roughly the same ($3.5 trillion) as China’s entire GDP as recently as 2007. China’s economy today is worth $18 trillion.

    Keep looking at the big picture…

  • D-Day Lesson For These Roaring ’20s?

    D-Day Lesson For These Roaring ’20s?

    The events of D-Day 80 years ago this week usually feature in the closing chapters of World War II history texts. My own current curiosity lies elsewhere, more focused on change and beginnings. Not the Reichstag fire, not Sudetenland, not Kristallnacht, not Lebensraum, not Poland. These were all events in the 1930s which historians agree shaped the outbreak of a global war. However, that decade of economic distress and social anger, whipped up by populism and propaganda, was probably inevitable. Indeed, it’s possible the seeds of war were sown much earlier. The previous decade known as the “Roaring Twenties” introduced huge economic, cultural and technology advances, but the 1929 crash and Great Depression which followed were the key catalysts for the global horror ahead. That lesson from history should not be forgotten. In fact, we should be on our guard. Welcome to the new Roaring ‘20s….

    It’s not just Reddit influencer, Keith “Roaring Kitty” Gill, reportedly banking hundred million dollar profits trading ‘meme-stocks’ like GameStop in recent days. There’s more than just a sense of giddiness about. Recall the 1920’s witnessed the arrival of mass-production and mass-consumerism as automobiles, electricity, cinema, radio and aviation made technology affordable to the middle class. And, then it wasn’t. Financial collapse and the implosion of banking leverage has been a feature of global economic cycles ever since 1929. It wasn’t a once-off in 1929. The global credit crisis in 2008-2009 proved that point, and then some. The critical factors in these financial earthquakes are excessive confidence and over-estimation of demand. First let’s illustrate confidence….

     

    • The S&P 500 benchmark index for global stock markets has not experienced a daily decline of 2% or more in 325 days (Source: Reuters).
    • The market capitalisation of a media company whose key ‘product’ and biggest shareholder is a convicted felon with presidential ambitions is currently over $8 billion (Source: Truth Social – just kidding!).
    • The private credit (lending) market has grown from $250 billion in 2010 to a whopping $1.7 trillion today (Source: Prequin).
    • This week AI chip maker, Nvidia, became the second most valuable private company in the world with a $3 trillion market capitalisation (Source: Bloomberg)

     

    Regular readers will know my views fall mainly on the optimistic side of AI. However, the odd sanity-check does no harm. Nvidia is a semiconductor manufacturer. In 2023 revenues generated by the entire semiconductor manufacturing sector globally reached $526 billion. So, for context, Nvidia’s market value is now six times the entire industry’s global revenue. I know analysts will talk about future AI spend, cash rich Big Tech customers and real demand, but there’s one other aspect to this growth story which is a little bit different with historical lessons.

    Legendary tech investor, Marc Andreessen, penned his “Why software is eating the world” essay in the Wall Street Journal in 2011 and there is no doubt software has embedded itself in every phone and corporation on the planet. The lovely thing about software is that it is embedded in an activity, generates recurring (frequent and relatively small) revenues and user stickiness/dependency is high. At a basic level software is code. It’s digital, not physical. Sure enough, coding platform giants Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Meta, Baidu, Alibaba etc. have dominated the league tables of most valuable companies in the world since the Andreessen prophecy. But, there has been a subtle recent shift in the value hierarchy.

    Consider that two of the three largest capitalised companies in the world are now HARDWARE manufacturers (Nvidia and Apple). Hardware is physical and brings an entirely different business model and a myriad of challenges including supply chain risks, materials, energy, sustainability, customer credit, consumer fashion, inventory management and capex investment. We don’t have a crystal ball in forecasting ultimate demand for AI but the semiconductor industry used to be known for its vicious cyclicality. With my risk history hat on, I’d venture there’s every chance this manufacturing sector will experience mismatches between supply and demand.  Of course, the automobiles and radios of the 1920’s might not resonate with today’s AI and technology enthusiasts. However, I’d highlight three other numbers which perhaps add to the “Roaring ‘20s” feel right now:

    Sport: The breakthrough of sports like boxing and athletics on a global scale was a feature of the 1920s but fans mostly followed events by radio. Now, it’s TV (or streaming). So, when basketball’s NBA is about to treble its broadcasting deal from $25 billion to $76 billion you do wonder about excess, and the projections of Amazon, NBC and ESPN? Maybe it’s the constant circling of private equity (PE) around US sport….? Latest data from Pitchbook research shows 63 US professional sports franchises have a PE ownership connection where PE involvement is allowed (NBA, MLS, NHL and MLB). Funnily enough, basketball (NBA) leads the way with two thirds of all teams in the league connected to PE.

    Securities: The 1920s saw the banks and their celebrity brokers on Wall Street begin to sell stock and bond securities to main street for the first time. Then came the ‘shoe shine’ moment in 1929.  Fast forward to today’s celebrities of the private equity universe and a recent FT report on that exclusive world. The headline-grabbing data point(and possibly harsh) suggests that, in the period 2010-2023, private equity funds raised $820 billion more than they actually returned to investors (Source: Prequin).

    Prohibition: Alcohol and gambling was the government target in the 1920s. So, remember when Bitcoin and its cryptocurrency ecosystem was dismissed by the ‘puritanical’ zeal of high street banks, regulators and law enforcement? Today, Bitcoin is trading above $71,000 and the total value of the crypto universe is $2.8 trillion. In fact, there are now billions of dollars invested in funds owning cryptocurrencies (ETFs) which trade daily on highly regulated public exchanges. Now, that’s a morality tale with a twist.

    Of course, the reference to Prohibition conjures up images of organised crime, judicial corruption, entire city governments ‘on the take’, high profile mob trials and flagrant violations of the rule of law. Couldn’t possibly happen again, could it?  Take that question with just a pinch of orange. On a more serious note, the erosion of the US rule of law is possibly a bigger threat in our immediate future than cyclical excess. Hopefully, the remembrance of D-Day sacrifice will remind those in power of their duty to call out faux (or Fox) ‘patriotism’. And, perhaps a read of the final speech in Charlie Chaplin’s The Great Dictator would help. Ironically, Chaplin’s own patriotism was questioned during a later shameful period (with my surname!) in US Congressional history. The Little Tramp’s words seem timely once again…

    Let us fight to free the world – to do away with national barriers – to do away with greed, with hate and intolerance. Let us fight for a world of reason, a world where science and progress will lead to all men’s happiness. Soldiers! in the name of democracy, let us all unite!    –  The Great Dictator (1940)